I wish society would stop touting marriage as the ultimate commitment. I don’t find anything special or particularly noteworthy of any couple that marries. And I’m definitely not impressed by people who get married. They’re no different than an unmarried committed couple. I’m not going to afford them any extra respect. And yet that’s seems to be an unwritten rule: If a couple is married you treat them differently. Why? What makes married couples so nifty? They stood up before friends and family and swore love until death do they part and exchanged rings? Whoop-de-fucking-do. Oh, wait, that’s right—they’re afforded certain privileges, such as tax benefits and the chance to share insurance. They’re also financially securing any children they have or will have. But you know what? Unmarried couples can do the same. But the government makes it a bit harder on single people, as do insurance companies. It’s all to ensure that people follow the traditional route and get married. Well, I say fuck that.
If it’s not about the insurance or the other financial benefits, then why get married? In case you didn’t know, divorce is expensive and—if things go sour between the couple—can be messy and difficult. It’s easier if you’re an unmarried couple, except when you get into common law situations. Married couples are just as likely to break up as any another couple. Why make it harder on yourself? The cost and potential messiness of divorce is sometimes what keeps an unhappy married couple together. Marriage is really just a risky business deal.
When I mention this to married folk, I tend to get the whole, “We made a commitment of our hearts not just our money!” Really? That can’t be accomplished without marriage? But if the first thing I mention is how you can have a committed, loving relationship without being married, I get the whole financial benefits spiel. Either way you approach it, a lot of married couples are determined to fiercely defend their marriage. Which I can understand, to a certain point. In their minds, these people have made the “ultimate commitment” to their partner, and whether or not they admit it, they see the sanctity of their marriage as something that should never be questioned.
Don’t get me wrong, I don’t go around bashing people for being married and not every couple thinks they’re special for having tied the knot. But a lot of them do and it’s absurd. The government certainly thinks married couples are better than unmarried ones. Of course, I don’t think the government should have anything to do with marriage. You shouldn’t get special tax benefits because you’re married. Or if you have kids, for that matter. If I had my druthers, marriage would be abolished.
While I think the typical arguments against gays getting married are bullshit, I don’t support gay marriage. But then I don’t support marriage period. I don’t understand the urge to get married. I understand wanting to spend your life with someone, but that’s where it ends. And if I ever reach a point in a relationship where I seriously consider marriage, I hope a friend or loved one is there to slap some sense into me.
If I knew a friend was getting married, I’d strongly encourage them to have a pre-nup done. Protect your belongings and money, people. You can say you love and trust your partner all you want, but people and their hearts can change and abysmal endings do happen to couples who were initially trusting and loving. People decry pre-nups as unromantic or a sign of commitment issues. I call it covering your ass should the unexpected happen and you’re left with nothing but your name. And if you take your spouse’s last name, even that is a costly hassle to have undone should divorce occur. I know some of you married folks are thinking, “But that’ll never happen to us! We love each other so much and would never hurt the other. We have the best relationship that’s ever existed!” Then you’ve got to stop and wonder, how many divorcees thought the exact same things when they got married?
I’m sure I’m pissing off a few married couples with this post, but I can’t say I really care. I don’t have a problem with you making a financial commitment to each other and your spawn no matter how ill conceived I think that decision is. Good on you if you don’t think your relationship is any better than an unmarried couples’. But personal feelings aside, society still thinks the ultimate commitment of head and heart (and wallet) is marriage. If one half of a couple wants to get married and the other doesn’t, the resisting one is labeled a commitment-phobe and gets lambasted for being afraid of commitment. They are treated like there is something wrong with them. People are pressured into getting married which is such a great way to start a marriage, don’t ya think? But the ones who do the pressuring just laugh it off as cold feet. Sure, some people are simply just afraid of marriage but really do want to take the plunge. But some are given no option, and if they leave the relationship, they get branded with the commitment-phobe label from then on.
So can we please, as a society, get the fuck over marriage and stop putting it on a pedestal? If you’re a would-be married person and you know me personally, please don’t get pissy when I’m unimpressed when you tell me you’re engaged or if I decline attending your wedding. And for the love of fuck don’t expect me to think your relationship with your spouse is special. I doubt I’ll even congratulate you. And that is awkward, the expected expression of congratulations. I’ve said it automatically in the past because it’s been ingrained into our minds that an impending marriage is to be congratulated. Anymore I simply say, “OK,” much to the chagrin of, well, everyone. But, you know, I just have commitment issues.




Sarahbear
While I can agree that marriage doesn’t make a relationship any more valid or special, I don’t really understand the desire to abolish marriage. If it’s something that some people choose to do, to have a celebration where they can promise their love to their partner in front of their closest friends and family, what’s wrong with congratulating them on their decision? What’s wrong with attending the party and supporting them?
People do shit all the time for reasons that other people think are ridiculous. If they want to do it, they have the means to do it and it makes them happier then it’s not really anyone’s business to criticize them for their choices.
.-= Sarahbear´s last blog ..Pleasurists #63 =-.
Kristi
“Of course, I don’t think the government should have anything to do with marriage. You shouldn’t get special tax benefits because you’re married. Or if you have kids, for that matter. If I had my druthers, marriage would be abolished.”
Perhaps I didn’t make it clear in that passage, but I’m for the abolition of marriage because it’s unfair to single people. Married couples get tax breaks. And if you have kids, even more breaks are on their way. Single people get taxed far more heavily. Until the government is removed from marriage and married couples are no longer treated better than single people, I will maintain my belief that it should be abolished. Couples can still have their little ceremonies, just keep the government out of it.
.-= Kristi´s last blog ..Worry wart =-.
Sarahbear
Yeah, the way your post sounded was more of a ‘getting married is stupid and people who want to get married or who are married are dumb for it.’ instead of ‘I disagree with the goverment’s involvement in marriage.’ Even in your response, the language you use in refering to couples and their ‘little ceremonies’ sounds a bit confrontational and belittling.
I still disagree with removing government from marriage because with any civilized society you will have taxes. Getting married and having children benefits our society financially and that’s why they get tax breaks. People who buy houses get tax breaks on their interest paid, as opposed to people who rent, but then they’re required to get home owners insurance and pay property taxes for their county. It all evens out in the long run.
.-= Sarahbear´s last blog ..Pleasurists #63 =-.
Rockin' with a Cock in
Wow, this was a good read, Kristi. I’ve recently begun questioning marriage (esp. the legal benefits side of it, but also the societal aspects of it) and have pretty similar views to you. It’s nice to see someone else with a familiar viewpoint. Thanks for sharing this with us.
I really don’t think “it all evens out in the long run” because in the long run I don’t think people getting married and having children benefits our society financially. I get that having more people in the world means that there are more people to spend money, but there are also more people who need jobs, food, space to live, and other things that aren’t so plentiful.
.-= Rockin’ with a Cock in´s last blog ..Numerous Non-Sticky Situations =-.
Kristi
Exactly! It does *not* all even out in the end. And, yeah, it’s nice to see someone who shares your viewpoint. Unfortunately, we’re a minority and the majority rules.
.-= Kristi´s last blog ..Worry wart =-.
Leigh
I was married in 92 because I had slept with the girl and it was the “right thing to do” because it was better to marry than to “live in sin” which was a HUGE MISTAKE. The best thing I got out of the marriage was my daughter.
After I separated I became involved with someone that I was entirely committed to and we ended up getting pregnant. We ended up getting married in 2000 before we wanted to for insurance purposes.
I agree that marriage is something that the government should NOT be involved in. While I do believe that there should be benefits for parents, they should be based on the child NOT the marital status of the parents.
For me and my wife, the marriage we had was simply to get insurance we joke that she married me for the money. We would have rather a ceremony that we enjoyed and was to celebrate our love.
Leigh
Damn my touch pad hit enter…
IMHO marriage, bonding, collaring and similar joining ceremonies are beautiful ceremony. However with the social and legal “requirement” of having a spouse and kids is entirely wrong.
I got married TOO young and divorce cost me a LOT of time, emotion and money. Had there not be in the gov’t involvement I could have walked away and gotten on with my life
The social and religious pressure for marriage are IMMENSE. The legal restrictions are sexist and exclusionary (i.e. poly unions)
It may seem that the benefits for having kids are incentive for having more and more kids, but this is not the case, as the tax breaks do not offset the immense cost of having a kid. Yes it is true that having a kid is a choice, but for me the breaks are not incentive but a way of surviving. Can I go and get another job to offset the cost? Nope because I have to take care of the kids and daycare costs would suck all the money that I would potentially earn in a second job.
I agree the legal aspects of marriage should be eliminated. This would remove the restrictions and benefits to “normal marriage” and let individuals decide or NOT decide what they will do.
Kristi
“However with the social and legal “requirement” of having a spouse and kids is entirely wrong.”
Agreed (obviously heh).
“The social and religious pressure for marriage are IMMENSE. The legal restrictions are sexist and exclusionary (i.e. poly unions).”
Very good point & now I’m wishing I had covered that in my post. lol
Airenwolf
WOW! Just as you are insisting that an unmarried couple be considered special so should a married couple, whatever their reasons for making the commitment. There are people who are naturally monogamous and desire a married state and ARE happy regardless of what ‘stitistics’ say. The problem isn’t with marriage it’s the fact that most people presume that marriage is the end goal. There is no thought paid to teaching the skills needed to nurture and grow the relationship so as to keep it fresh and relevant to the needs and changing views of the participants.
Having said that yes I was pressured and outright forced to get married, which I regret. Still I regret the fact that my getting married didn’t have the desired outcome ie: my parents acceptance of my husband as someone I am going to be with for a lifetime if we can manage it. I don’t regret marrying him though, nor do I regret not being single. I am polyamorous and polyfidelitous…if I could I’d marry our life partner as well just because I LIKE the sense of final commitment that marriage means to ME. Barring that I too would like to see the institution in it’s current incarnation abandoned.
There really shouldn’t be any monetary benefit to being married, we are all supposed to be equal under the law and free to pursue our own brand of happiness providing it doesn’t hurt anyone.
Having tax breaks for kids is a good idea, we need all the help we can get from our money grubbing government BUT those breaks should be available to EVERY household with children not a select few who conformed to a narrow majority’s views about sex and love.
I have to agree with Leigh as well, the married tax breaks don’t even make a dent in the money we spend on our children so it’s not an incentive to have more and more kids.
Having reservations and being worried is a sign of a good friend but in the end a really good friend can still say congratulations on your choice even if it isn’t the same one I’d make! My best friend had major reservations about my marriage but still supported me over her parents protestations. She was a witness to my JOTP wedding and wished me all the happiness I could experience while stating that she thought I was silly for getting married because my parents wanted me too.
Kristi
“Having tax breaks for kids is a good idea, we need all the help we can get from our money grubbing government BUT those breaks should be available to EVERY household with children not a select few who conformed to a narrow majority’s views about sex and love.”
Fair enough.
Rayne
Excellent points, babe.
M and I got married because that makes me his in the eyes of the law as well. It had nothing to do with finances, but a lot do to with love. We were both broke before we got married and we’re still broke now. Lol. If anything, getting married made our financial situation worse, not better.
I come from traditional family (that is slowly learning tradition isn’t all it’s cracked up to be through divorce and broken hearts) so that had a little bit of influence on my decision as well. But both of us realize that the piece of paper we signed and the vows we took in front of 30 strangers changes nothing when it comes to our hearts. We loved each other before we got married and we love each other now.
.-= Rayne´s last blog ..M’s Eureka Moment and Verbal Commands =-.
Kristi
“If anything, getting married made our financial situation worse, not better. ”
Well, that’s not very comforting to would-be married couples. lol
Juliettia
Seriously?
Adriana
I do not agree with the aggressive tone of this overall. It’s hard to when I am married and I like it that way. However, you do make some valid points. Before my mom was married, she and her boyfriend (the father of her child) had really weird insurance and child support issues because they weren’t married but they were living in the same house. That kinda stuff is perplexing at best.
I think whatever someone wants to do with his or her life is great. Marriage should not be the end game for all people. And I would say that the assumption that it should be is a bigger issue than marriage itself. Still, I think that making and keeping such a commitment (and in front of friends and family) is commendable, not because it’s marriage but because it is hard work and does take a lot. Granted, many marriages do fail (and are maybe destined to fail from the start) and being realistic about them is great but, then again, so do many aspirations fail but it doesn’t mean we should prevent people from trying does it?
I think sometimes there is some animosity because it seems like marriage affords people are sorts of privileges but in the real world, those privileges may not exist at all or may come at a high price.
.-= Adriana´s last blog ..The Cold Hard Truth is.. =-.
Dorine Parado
I just love this
Kristi S (@KristiS77)
@AshlyStar Ah, well, I just remember I wrote about this for @EdenCafe. Here ya go: http://t.co/ojU2gqP