Here’s Part 1

He untied my scarf slowly, “Did you like the thrill, Stefanie?” Sorry if I scared you. That’s always been a fantasy of mine.

“What is a fantasy of yours?” I asked – I didn’t understand quite what he meant.

He cleared his throat, as he caught his breath, and all I could think about was getting more of him. I hadn’t climaxed yet, and neither had he. “To take control of a girl during sex while wearing a scary costume. To make her think I was a stranger, but still want me. I’m surprised you actually wanted me. You’re so beautiful and I’m nothing compared to you. You could have any guy you wanted.”

“You could have any girl you wanted if you showed them that cock,” I said jokingly, but very truthful, as he is huge. “Nonetheless, you are a very handsome guy. Don’t say that. However, please tell me you will take me home and give me a good fucking tonight. Neither of us came and I think we both need it.”

Just as I had before, he put his hand in mine, and I led him down the block to my apartment. This time his manner was more gentle. I like a bit of kink every now and then, but I like to end off things a little less kinky and more romantically, with a little spanking here and there. I could already tell he was just like me by the way his voice softened.

The next 10 minutes home was filled with conversation about what we had just done. Neither of us could believe that we actually lived our fantasies in one night – together. I couldn’t help but stare at his crotch, where his cock was still bulging from his erection. I wondered what he was thinking about that was keeping him so erect. Is he thinking about what we just did? Is it the fact that he thinks I’m beautiful? Questions ran through my head, and I was excited to know that someone wanted me just as much as I wanted them.

We arrived at my apartment, and he held my book bag and scarf as I unlocked the door. We walked inside, and I asked him to make himself at home while I freshened up. “I’ll be honest, I’m quite sweaty from all that, and I’d rather smell good while we finish this whole thing. Feel free to look around, watch some TV, or grab a bite to eat. I won’t be too long.”

I walked to my bedroom and lit a few candles. The place smelled like absolutely nothing, and I love to smell my cinnamon vanilla candle while I’m having sex. I made the bed nicely, and picked up a pair of panties and my bra of the floor and threw them in the hamper. I organized my books, closed the curtains, and attempted to hide my large collection of sex toys so that I didn’t come off as a freak – but then again, we both just had sex with someone we hardly knew in a park.

I stepped into the restroom and the lights were already on. I must have forgotten to turn them off this morning. I can’t keep doing that, my bill is too high. I slipped out of my clothes, examining the scratches and bites all over my body. It was making me wet all over again to think about everything Tyler had done to me in the park. I realized that I had taken so long cleaning and staring at myself that Tyler might have fallen asleep or gotten bored and left, so I opened the shower curtains and turned the water on.

“Boo!” A completely different voice shouted. Okay, who the hell is it now and how did they get in my damn apartment? “Stefanie, it’s me! Kristen!” I looked up to see Kristen’s beautiful body, entirely naked except for a pair of devil horns, a sequin-covered mask, and two red sparkly pasties. She was shivering in my shower, and I wondered how long she had been waiting. Kristen was my old roommate from the last year. She slept over from time to time, and we made out occasionally when we were drunk, but she was gone this entire semester in Florida. I had no idea she was coming home.

Kristen and I talked about having sex a few times. She was lesbian, and I was simply curious. I didn’t mind the idea of sex with a woman, but I could never date one, and I was afraid she would want that even though she assured me she didn’t. She looked hotter than ever, and I wasn’t sure what to do.

I thought quietly myself, but before I knew it she was stroking my neck and had her soft hands all over my pussy. She moved her fingers up and down my slit slowly, rubbing my clit and tracing the entrance to my vagina. I was dying for her to finger me, but she just kept teasing. I hope Tyler doesn’t freak out when he finds out she’s here.

“I have a surprise for you, Stefanie,” Kristen said as she held up a double dong made of glass that I had wanted for over a year. I talked about buying it all the time, but couldn’t afford the price of $125. “It’s for you, sweetie. Would you like to use it with me tonight?”

I smiled as I massaged her breasts up against the wall of the shower “Of course I would. But you have to wait until a friend leaves. He’s right outside in the living room.” I said, hoping she wouldn’t be turned off.

“Actually girls, I’m right here,” Tyler said, staring at us. I didn’t even hear him walk in! “You didn’t tell me it was going to be a party, Stefanie, but you can count me in. Are you girls ready for the night of your life?”

We both nodded as he took off his clothes and stepped into the shower with us. Both Kristen and I were getting aroused, and her big pink clit started to peek out from her labia as she watched Tyler wash me down with body wash. “You’re next,” he said to Kristen, as he held one of her perfect breasts in his hands. I was in complete heaven in that shower, and I couldn’t imagine how amazing the rest of the night would be.

I watched Tyler wash Kristen off, removing one pastie at a time to reveal her hard pink nipples that were begging to be suckled. He got behind her and began massaging her breasts as I spread her legs and began to get my first taste of pussy. It was natural, and tasted a little different from mine. More salty, but I craved more and more of her. I sucked her clit and she screamed harder, so I began to suck more and more of her pussy into my mouth until she just couldn’t take it.

I turned the shower off to let everyone know that it was time to go to the bedroom. We failed to even dry off, for we were so excited to explore one another. Kristen was the first to get laid down on the bed, and surprisingly I was the one to do it. I thought I’d let Tyler have a show before we fucked him.

I laid her head against the headboard on a pillow, and made sure she was relaxed and ready to play. I kissed her lips and sucked on her tongue, as I fingered her clit. Kristen moaned and squirmed, begging me for more head. I slowly kissed her down her face, onto her neck, across her chest – making sure to spend plenty of time sucking and caressing each breast – and down her belly until I reached her delicious pussy. I inserted the dildo and slowly thrusted as I licked Kristen’s clit.

After a few minutes, I laid myself back and put the other end of the dildo into my own pussy, and we started to fuck one another slowly, taking care not to go too hard. Unfortunately, slowly and softly wasn’t good enough, so we started to thrust hard until it hurt – but it hurt so good. Meanwhile, Tyler watched, pulling at the skin on his cock and ready to get in the action.

Tyler started off somewhat straddling us both, putting his cock in my face for me to suck while he ate Kristen’s pussy, satisfying her need for more head. I couldn’t get enough of the taste of Tyler’s salty precum as he pushed his cock into my mouth, deeper and deeper, over and over. Both Kristen and I moaned in ecstasy.

After that, Kristen laid Tyler down and started to ride his cock. As she rode him like a horse, I put my thighs around his head so he could eat my pussy for a while. I clenched on to the headboard because his tongue movements were so fast and intense that I feared I would squirt all over his face. Not a thought went through my mind, just pleasure through my body.

Kristen and I switched places, and I rode Tyler so hard that my pussy started to swell, and I felt my cunt get ready to squirt. “I’m getting close; I’m gonna cum,” Tyler said as I was grinding my clit against him as hard as I could in hopes to orgasm as I squirted. Kristen had already cum several times from the amazing head Tyler was giving her.

Not even five minutes later, Tyler and I both let out deep breaths as we neared climax. I let out a loud moan, and he spanked my ass as I squirted and came all over his cock. I could feel his hot white cum filling my pussy and running back down his cock. Kristen was behind me now massaging my breasts and pushing my new dildo in and out of my tight asshole. It was the most pleasureful orgasm I had ever had in my life.

Tired and worn out, Tyler dressed and kissed us both. “I’m gonna head out now. Thank you so much for tonight, ladies. I’ve never had anything as wonderful as this. I’ll never forget it.” We jokingly rubbed his sore cock and smacked his butt on the way out the door.

“It’s just you and me now, Kristen. Are you ready for bed?” I asked. She seemed tired, and both of us were still catching our breath.

“Not just yet, darling. Will you stay up with me a while?” Kristen asked sheepishly.

“Of course I will. So tell me, babe. What have you got planned now?”